|
Hey everyone, My wife tries to replicate it and admits it’s never the same, and recently I heard her mom go, “Well, it’s just a pinch of…” and “Just add ‘some’ sugar.” I got inspired watching my wife and her mother bicker. To mom, it’s a complete recipe. To my wife, it’s an impossible riddle. The better you get at something, the harder it becomes to remember what it felt like to NOT know it. Researchers call it the curse of knowledge. As the educator, you’re the expert. This issue is about the steps you skip while teaching without realizing it, and how to find them again. Another Lens I taught this work in an art course for non-majors. One student was so stuck on the letters and numbers that they failed to realize the purpose was to create the shadow. One More Lens Only because I’m really enjoying making this point from different angles, and you’ll appreciate this one… There’s a 1990 Stanford study by Elizabeth Newton where people tapped out well-known songs on a table and predicted how many listeners would guess the song. Tappers thought about 50% of listeners would guess it. The actual share of listeners who guessed correctly? 2.5%!!!!! (3 out of 120) Why? The tappers heard the full melody in their heads. The listeners heard… This study homed in on the curse of knowledge, a cognitive bias where experts unknowingly assume others have the context needed to understand. How to Catch Yourself When you say “From the pickup!” before counting in, you assume A LOT of prerequisite knowledge. That’s the curse of knowledge at work. EVERYONE has this type of bias at some point. You, me, my mother-in-law and her so-called “recipe.” The goal isn’t to get rid of it (you can’t). The best we can do is catch it in the moment. Listen for the Red Flag Words
Know Where Complexity Hides Once you’ve caught yourself, look for the hidden steps in three places: Vocabulary | Words and symbols you stopped noticing years ago (aka “jargon”). Pickup, downbeat, intervals, etc. Prerequisites | Processes that are automatic for you but still take effort for them. Counting rests, reading ledger lines, finding beat 4. Simultaneity | (I have to read this word 4 times to say it right in my head) Things you do at the same time without thinking. Reading, counting, breathing, even just listening to the person next to you. Where have I caught myself the most? Recently, while teaching my own children to tie their shoes… cognitive bias EEEEEEVERYWHERE! Strategies to Design Around Cognitive Bias Finally, something to DO “Where’d I Lose You?” 🧪 Try this
Those clusters are your cognitive bias, finally made visible! 📏 Measure Tally the “lost me” marks by step. Re-sequence the lesson to break down the top 2 hot spots. Next time you teach it (or a very similar topic), track time to mastery (or the number of reps it takes) and compare. Peer Explainers Here’s a secret weapon: your learners who JUST figured something out. They still remember what it felt like not to know it. (Also peer education is one of the most effective learning strategies 😉) 🧪 Try this
📏 Measure Track how many learners master the skill after a peer explanation compared to after your explanation alone. If peers win, don’t take it personally. Take notes. Your Thoughts What’s a skill you’ve done so long you often struggle to explain it? How do you break it down for learners? Updates from the Music Room 6 NEW FREE Pieces🎶 Chamber Mallet Music Petals on Rosewood (Grade 2, Duet on 1 Marimba) Three Lemons (Grade 2, Trio on 1 Marimba) Guitar Ensemble | A video on the inspiration for these works Where the Marigolds Bloom (Grade 2, 2-Part) No One Waiting (Grade 1, 3-Part) Afterglow (Grade 1, 2-Part) Click any title to hear a preview. Request free scores and parts for any of these here. Conference Reminders🗣️ I’m leading a workshop, “The Sound of Thinking: Managing Cognitive Load” at both (yes, the curse of knowledge makes an appearance): MMEA State Conference (Feb. 5–6) TMEA Convention (Feb. 10–13) Previous Issue: AI Whiplash |
PIXEL is the pen name of composer and educator Evan Combs. This playfully academic newsletter offers a behind-the-scenes look at designing and shaping learning experiences and culture. Supported by practical insights and actionable strategies, it’s perfect for teachers, leaders, and anyone curious about the art and science of learning through the lens of music.
Hey everyone, Picture a high school senior’s day at school… Period 2: “If I catch you using AI, it’s a zero.” Period 4: “AI will rot your brain, you need to think for yourself.” Period 6: “AI is destroying civilization as we know it.” Four years later, they sit in a job interview and hear: “So, walk us through how you use AI in your workflow.” Recent Grad: “I was told there would be no AI” That’s the whiplash we’re creating, and I get a front-row seat to both ends of it. By day, I design...
Hey everyone, Imagine I’m your boss. I walk up to you and say: “Next time you’re in front of learners, you’re not allowed to speak. And you need to teach the next three sessions like this.” I slap a new unit of content on your desk and walk away. You’d all be like… Except what I REALLY meant was: “You’re going to pilot a new project-based unit where learners drive the discussion and their own work. I trust your instincts as a seasoned educator, and I want your feedback to help make this...
A year ago, I wrote an issue about building classroom culture from Day 1 (Start as You Mean to Go On - as a refresher). A year later... I'd change one thing. Culture doesn't start on Day 1, it starts before Day 1. It starts with: The agreements you’ve chosen to surface. The routines you’ve chosen to establish. The invisible curriculum you’ve chosen to value. Over the last year, I’ve written about: Cognitive rigor Project-based learning Learning through failure Cross-curricular thinking...